The Supreme Court has rejected Karnataka government's appeal against the removal of the bike taxi ban, allowing services to continue while emphasising regulation over a complete prohibition.
The Supreme Court has dismissed the Karnataka government's appeal challenging the High Court's decision to lift the ban on bike taxi services. The ruling provides significant relief to bike taxi aggregators and passengers across the state, as the High Court's order will continue to remain in force.
A bench comprising Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and N Kotiswar Singh delivered the decision on Friday after hearing arguments from the state government, ride-hailing companies and other parties. During the hearing, the court observed that regulating bike taxi services would be a more practical approach than imposing a complete ban.
While explaining the importance of bike taxi services, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma referred to a conversation with women working in his office who regularly used these services.
He said he had asked them how they travelled to his office. They replied that they preferred motorcycles because hiring a cab was expensive. When he suggested using an autorickshaw, they explained that its fare could be around five times higher than a bike taxi.
Justice Sharma highlighted that affordable transportation was an important reason behind the popularity of these services. He also pointed out that bike taxis offer GPS-based tracking, which can provide an additional safety feature for passengers.
The judge observed that bike taxis were already operating in 25 states across the country. According to him, introducing suitable rules and safety measures would be more beneficial than stopping the services altogether.
During the proceedings, the Supreme Court also examined the Karnataka government's concerns about traffic congestion caused by bike taxi operations.
The bench questioned the state's position, observing that motorcycles generally occupy less road space than cars. This raised questions about whether traffic congestion could be a sufficient reason to prohibit bike taxis.
The state government, however, maintained that motorcycles and motor cabs were treated as separate categories under the Motor Vehicles Act. Its counsel argued that Karnataka's existing rules for ride-hailing aggregators did not specifically provide for bike taxi operations.
The government also submitted that aggregators could not claim an automatic right to operate bike taxis. To support its position, it referred to a 2019 expert committee report that examined issues such as passenger safety, road congestion and pollution.
During the hearing, the Karnataka government indicated that it was willing to examine the possibility of permitting bike taxi services in other parts of the state. However, it maintained that such services should not be allowed in Bengaluru.
The government's concerns were primarily related to passenger safety, insurance protection and the absence of adequate safeguards for bike taxi operators and users.
Several auto-rickshaw and taxi driver associations had also opposed the High Court's decision. They argued that allowing bike taxis without imposing similar regulatory conditions could create an uneven playing field for traditional transport operators.
Representatives of bike taxi companies defended their services before the Supreme Court. They informed the bench that approximately 4.5 lakh passengers in Karnataka had benefited from bike taxi services.
The aggregators also referred to an earlier High Court ruling that had not been challenged. In addition, they relied on Central Government notifications issued in 2004 and 2024, arguing that these notifications permitted motorcycles to be used as taxis.
The Central Government also submitted that its notifications allowed motorcycles to operate as taxis, supporting the position taken by the aggregators.
Senior advocate Abhishek Singhvi represented Uber during the proceedings. Senior advocates Vikas Singh and Parag Tripathi appeared on behalf of the Karnataka government.
The latest Supreme Court decision follows a January 23 order of the Karnataka High Court, which set aside the restrictions imposed on bike taxi services.
The High Court directed the state government to register motorcycles as transport vehicles and issue the necessary carriage permits, allowing them to operate as bike taxis.
The order came after appeals were filed by ANI Technologies, Uber India and Roppen Transportation Services against an earlier single-judge bench decision that had prohibited bike taxi operations.
Following the High Court's ruling, the Karnataka government approached the Supreme Court, challenging the decision on several grounds, including passenger safety, insurance coverage and the lack of adequate regulatory safeguards.
The Karnataka government had prohibited app-based ride-hailing aggregators from operating bike taxi services on June 16, 2025. The restriction had affected companies offering motorcycle-based transportation through their mobile applications.
However, with the Supreme Court dismissing the state's appeal, the Karnataka High Court's January 23 order remains effective.
This means the state government will have to proceed in accordance with the High Court's directions regarding the registration of motorcycles as transport vehicles and the issuance of carriage permits.
The ruling also brings attention to the need for a clear regulatory framework covering bike taxi operations, passenger safety, insurance and the responsibilities of aggregators.
For passengers, the decision offers relief as bike taxi services can continue under the applicable legal framework. It also reinforces the Supreme Court's view that regulation, rather than a blanket ban, should be considered when addressing concerns surrounding these services.